Gooseberry will be closed to new online orders from Dec 19th - Jan 4th. Thank you to all of our customers!

Valentine’s Sweetheart Pie


*** Order by Feb 10 for Pickup on Feb 13 or 14 ***

Send all the right messages to your valentine this year with a Sweetheart pie.  Choose from one of our rich and delicious fruit-filled pies.  If you would like to customize some or all of the messages on the hearts, include the details in the ‘Written Message’ section.  Otherwise, we will use the messages we all know and love.

Located in Bentonville, AR, Gooseberry Handmade Pies brings that homemade taste in every bite. Chef Paul & Abbie Frintrup craft each pie by hand using only the best fresh fruit and ingredients.

Select a Filling

Save to Favorites
Save to Favorites

Frosting Happiness Guarantee

  • Check Mark Shop with confidence
  • Check Mark Approved bakeries
  • Check Mark Purchase protection

Click to Share


Gooseberry only uses the best fruits and ingredients in our pies. To guarantee freshness, your pie is made to order.

Size & Servings
Large pies are 10″ and serve approximately 8 – 10 people.
Mini pies are 5″ and serve 1 – 2 people.

Cold Pie: Keep covered and refrigerated.  Your cold pie will keep in the refrigerator for up to 5 days.

Fruit & Nut Pies: We recommend leaving your pie covered and at room temperature.  If left at room temperature, each pie is best enjoyed within 3 days.  To prolong shelf life, you may keep in the refrigerator for up to 1 week.

Allergy Info
Please note that everything is produced in a facility containing known food allergens, including, but not limited to: eggs, wheat, soy, milk, peanuts, and tree nuts.

Pickup Information
Your order will be ready for pickup at Gooseberry’s Shop in Bentonville on the day you select.
2210 S. Walton Blvd Ste 12
Bentonville, AR 72712

If you need a pie in less than 24 hours please contact us during normal business hours: 479-224-1318

Pickup Hours
Monday – Friday: 11:00am – 5:00pm
Saturday: 10:00am – 12:00pm (noon)

Please use the Contact link on my store page.

Customer Reviews

No reviews yet